Отзывы о книге

ArtMagicGirl14
Apr 03, 2021
Bitter Virgin review
"Bitter Virgin" is a step above the normal seinen drama fare and definitely aimed at more mature readers due to the themes it handles, which include: rape, pregnancy, abortion, single motherhood, adoption and still birth. If the aforementioned list of tragic circumstances sounds like a recipe or cocktail of depression to you, then it's almost guaranteed that you understand what "Bitter Virgin" is about.

That being said, the manga is very accessible because although the subject matter is serious, the characters are introspective and for the most part remarkably mature while still remaining in character as teenagers. Some traditional manga tropes are present like the wishy washy male protagonist or the love-lorn childhood friend, but these never come to dominate the plot.

For the most part I felt that the characters were well done and nothing in the plot approached absurd levels of melodrama, which is always a risk with these types of plot lines. That being said, there were still plenty of cliff hangers and tear jerking moments as you would expect given the dramatic nature of this story.

The art itself is crisp and well defined, with Kusunoki's particular style being close to what you might associate with shoujo or josei manga, but with bolder lines and less sharp and slightly more "moe" features. She also has quite a talent with panel layout and story pacing, so each page is a breeze to read instead of being a distracting mess.

On the whole, "Bitter Virgin" is an excellent drama and love story with an unusually serious premise. If you can handle the themes it presents then I think most people will quite enjoy it.
0
0
0
finwatchin077
Apr 03, 2021
Bitter Virgin review
First things first: I read this whole manga in 1 day which could be reason enough for some, to read it too
Second: I never wrote a review before, but i just can't keep quiet about this

As for the ratings:
Story: 9
If I had to describe the story of Bitter Virgin in only one sentence, I'd just say "It's something else". If you're bored by the everyday shoujo manga, with they all-is-well school days atmosphere, then you're right here. I don't want to reveal too much, as you should read it yourself, but this is about a "dark" side of the not so everyday life, which i don't remember to be shown anywhere else (neither manga nor anime)

Art: 7

Not too bad, but nothing special either so a "good" should be ok for it

Character: 9

The tragic protagonist Hinako, together with the also tragic sister, which rises from the support to a main character (in my eyes) are the core of this drama and u can easily get lost in their despair and struggling. they both get support from Daisuke, who undergoes a change for the better with time passing by.

Spoiler, so be warned about the next lines
The only reason, why I don't give the full 10 points here, is cause of the typical, as I phrase for myself, bitching-around-attitude in the end (meaning the "Oh no, I better go away and leave for good, cause else I might hurt the one i love")
Spoiler end

Enjoyment: 10

Well...I read it in one day, so i don't have to say more about enjoyment

Overall: 9

If someone asked me for a manga he could read next, Bitter Virgin would definitely be a suggestion :D
0
0
0
VaskoKasko12
Apr 03, 2021
Bitter Virgin review
This manga is about two topics mainly: pregnancy and loss associated with it, and rape.

In the behind-the-scenes bonus comics the author explains that she's gone through giving birth to a stillborn child and based that side of her work on her own experiences. It goes a long way towards explaining why those themes are explored very thoughtfully and completely. I have no complaints there. In fact it deserves some praise for being fairly unflinching with regards to the situations AND the emotions involved. I brought up the author's experience because it comes through. It's intimate, personal stuff.

The themes of rape... are not quite as well handled. It's not a total rock bottom all the time and will occasionally connect in the way it was intended to, but it slips into questionable territory enough that I felt like writing this as a bit of a warning to those who might need it. A lot of this manga feels like your typical shoujo romance drama, but the "hook" is that the loner girl the main character is in love with had been routinely raped by her stepfather throughout middle school and eventually impregnated. It's a dark way to look at the material, but it is what it is and some of the cliches used here become outrageously bleak in this context.

Specifically the obligatory rival girl, who in this context is required to reach such high levels of pure evil that it starts feeling like a pure trash soap opera. There's an EXTREME level of tonal whiplash whenever this character appears.

At one point the girl is put into a "Guy Saves Her From A Random Sexual Assault" scene. You know the type of scene I'm talking about. It shows up a lot, but in this case it's not only graphic in its depiction but it's especially dark given the character's history. This girl's been victimized over and over again since middle school, bu this sudden reoccurrence of sexual violence years later is recovered from almost immediately. The foremost thought on her mind is only how grateful she is to her guy friend for pummeling her attacker within an inch of his life. See what I mean by cliche shoujo with an unfortunate twist? Something like that should probably introduce some HEAVY pathos into the situation, maybe even to the extent of a complete emotional breakdown, but it's treated like a love flag of all things.

Oddly enough, by the last half of the story the 'rape stuff' kind of slides into the background in favor of the pregnancy themes. It's perhaps a better move since that stuff is so much better considered, but it's weird to see the characters fretting over the fact that the main girl's secret is that "she used to be pregnant" while failing to recognize that she was made pregnant by her step-father and rapist. It's also unfortunate that a lot of the conclusions come down to the guy saying, "I'll protect you!" in that typical manga way that's just not good enough here.
0
0
0
CaptureRide5
Apr 03, 2021
Bitter Virgin review
Edit: I am keeping this review because it's my first one i ever wrote in 2011. If i was to read this manga again my opinion of it might have been changed or i wouldn't rate it this high anymore.

Hello, this is my first review, it's quite short but spoiler free. I'm writing this because I want others to read this manga, whether you are guy or a girl. I think it really teaches you to value life better, that when you are given something, you should be happy, because you are lucky to have it in your life. :)

I'm glad that when i started to read it, i had only read half of the summary, because i didn't know what kind of ''secret'' the main girl has.
I thought it was another common love manga, so i just clicked the first pages through and until I see what her ''secret'' was, and then decide whether i should drop it or continue reading it.. but dang i was wrong to think it would be bad.. so wrong.. because this manga imo turned out so great! GREAT.. oh yeah, 10 stands for OUTSTANDING :D!



What i really loved was that how the main guy started to care about the girl when he found out about her secret, the fact that he didn't even understand at first that he was in love with her. It was just so cute seeing him blush like that whenever he saw her.
And the main girl was so weak and so strong at the same time. It's hard to explain without spoiling anything, so you should just read it yourself.
And the story with the main guy's sister touched me deeply, that was really something.


Anyways, if you want something short, but decent and something that teaches you to value something better then go ahead and read it now. :)
Or read it until you get to know the secret and then decide. If you can, don't read the summary at all, and let the manga itself surprise you.
0
0
0
Ginorin11
Apr 03, 2021
Bitter Virgin review
Story:10
This story conveys a lot of tragedy but in the end it is a bittersweet story. Kudos to author for telling us this story, I suspect that author had some kind experience with all of that or at the very least had some investigation made before writing this it feels real not your usual bull crappy romcom or even romance seinen. It shows social stigma, fears and ordinary people who like to brag since heck most of the people are bragging garbage spewers. I should say that it is hard to describe this manga with words since it shows the ugly side of human nature whilst doesn't forget to show that humans can also show their bright side at the unexpected moments.
By the way ending is open ended - Hence USE your imagination of how things will be in the future a poetic end i should say and RIGHT HERE IT IS JUSTIFIED, some moronic authors use open ended endings in stupid situations (since manga was so far from realty and they simply put some salt to sweet manga in order to seem more mature as an author) this manga deserves this ending and I'm not disappointed

Art:9
Not my cup of tea but like previously stated it is mix of josei and seinen, most likely due to josei being for women and shoujo or josei drawings creep me out (too girly for me i guess). But here it is actually good but again it is a mix and not quite what i like. Characters are drawn good and made to be likeable besides MC male friend (he is creepy looking one) as for other they look good. Background animation also is made quite good. As for text bubbles they are readable but sometimes annoying placement of panels is a little bit irritating but seen worse :)

Character:10
I saw growth starting from chapter one, with every passing chapter we reveal something new about characters life, their character and their change. The most despicable character grows and becomes likeable (Rare thing) some you start to hate (not hate but more like their image being smeared). And most of all characters are not shallow they have life inside of them. All in all thank you author for the character development, you truly put your time on creating this (if not reproducing it from IRL).

Enjoyment:10
Enjoyed from chapter 1 till chapter 32. This story was too fast for me (I WANTED MOAR!), sometimes you see crap having over 73 chapters(reference from my last review) and sometimes you see a masterpiece with no more than 10 chapters. But a wise thing it is to stop at the right moment when it is needed, to make a masterpiece. Not too much and not too little a balance I call it .

Overall:9
I subjectively would have given rated it 10 but to be more objective reviewer i can't place it more than 9. It was cool and all but looking at it coldly it had one distinct drawback....MC heroine had too many accidents
*Spoiler Alert*
Falling, attempted rape, exposure (of her secrets by accidents), classmate harassment and it made me think that author pushed too much misfortune on one character in order to make this story darker and more appealing to empathetic people.
0
0
0
Bitter Virgin
Bitter Virgin
Автор Kusunoki, Kei
Художник --