Hi no Tori

Написать отзыв
Стать господином
Альтернативы: Synonyms: Phoenix Early Works, Shojo Club, Shoujo Club-han
Japanese: 火の鳥
Автор: Tezuka, Osamu
Тип: Манга
Объемы: 1
Главы: 19
Положение дел: Finished
Публиковать: 2021-05-06 to 2021-12-06
Сериализация: Shoujo Club

Чтение

Хочу почитать

Читать

удалять

Чтение

Хочу почитать

Читать

удалять

4.0
(1 Голоса)
0.00%
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0 Чтение
0 Хочу почитать
0 Читать
Альтернативы: Synonyms: Phoenix Early Works, Shojo Club, Shoujo Club-han
Japanese: 火の鳥
Автор: Tezuka, Osamu
Тип: Манга
Объемы: 1
Главы: 19
Положение дел: Finished
Публиковать: 2021-05-06 to 2021-12-06
Сериализация: Shoujo Club
Счет
4.0
1 Голоса
0.00%
100.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0.00%
0 Чтение
0 Хочу почитать
0 Читать
Резюме
Hi no Tori (1956-57), is Osamu Tezuka's second crack at its concept. When it came time to work on a new series as a follow-up to the very popular Ribbon no Kishi (1953-56), Tezuka decided to return to the story begun in Hi no Tori serialized in Manga Shonen (1954-55)—one that had been abruptly cut short by the sudden demise of the magazine a year earlier. However, instead of simply trying to continue the story from where it had been left hanging, Tezuka decided to reboot the series completely. Drawing, the chapters "Egypt, Greece, and Rome," with its setting in ancient Europe, Again, however, this was never completed.

(Source: tezukainenglish.com)
Отзывы (1)
Написать отзыв
Hi no Tori review
к
Angra-Mainyu14
Apr 09, 2021
Phoenix(1956) is split up into three arcs. I feel like each of them deserve individual scoring which will be averaged to get my final ratings. This review will be as spoiler-free as possible.

Egypt Arc:
Story: 8
A look at an Egyptian power struggle with the Phoenix shaping history. This arc easily had the most compelling story.
Art: 7
Tezuka has his unique art style that is used throughout all of his works. This one doesn't stand out so I give it my default art rating.
Character: 7
This is the only arc where the main characters get much development. They are good but nothing special even here.
Enjoyment: 8
Didn't have the overall impact Tezuka's works usually do but it was a fun tale nonetheless.

Greece Arc:
Story: 7
The Trojan horse story(overused) in which Daia and Krav play a crucial role that is a pretty good read
Art: 7
Same as Egypt
Character: 6
After the first arc, the main characters reset and end up basically defaulting to the same characters in the first arc
Enjoyment: 8
This arc should have had an original story like the other two but it was the longest and had some good moments.

Rome Arc:
Story: 7
A very basic but kinda cool Roman story that didn't make much sense.
Art: 7
Same as Greece
Character: 6
The main characters reset again and don't really get much focus.
Enjoyment: 7
Seemed like there should have been more time put into this one but it was pretty fun

Manga Overall:
Story: 7
The stories, when read together, paint a picture of the lives of Daia, Krav and Chirol.
Art: 7
Art isn't something I almost ever care about. I will give it a 7 if I don't find things I hate or love about it.
Character: 6
The characters just didn't get enough focus outside of the first arc and they weren't much to brag about even then.
Enjoyment: 8
This is a fun trip through history. Not nearly as thought-provoking as most Tezuka works. Maybe if it got finished, it would have been.

Being unfinished, this story has a huge hole in it as far as closure goes. The characters are too pushed aside to be really good. Bottom line: This manga needed more chapters.